Split Decision Pie Pan: Dinner and Dessert
Chicken Pot Pie and Apple Pie all in one dish with the Split Decision Pie Pan! When Chicago Metallic first sent me their Split Decision Pie Pan, I thought long and hard about what 2 pies I wanted to make. At first I was leaning towards 2 different flavors of fruit pie. But then, Stephen presented the idea of using the pie dish to create a whole meal in one adorable little pie. So, we ran with it!

Ingredients
For the chicken pot pie:
For the apple pie:
Instructions
For the chicken pot pie
- Step 1
Pre-heat oven to 400 degrees F
- Step 2
Season the chicken on both sides with salt and pepper. In a medium skillet over medium high heat, cook the chicken in the broth until done and at an internal temperature of 165 degrees F. Once done, remove from heat (reserving the cooking liquid), let cool slightly, and shred.
- Step 3
In skillet, combine 1/2 cup of the saved cooking liquid (if all of your broth cooked off, add in additional 1/2 cup of chicken broth), milk, and flour. Cook on low until the sauce thickens which should only take a couple minutes.
- Step 4
Once the sauce is thick, add in the parsley, shredded chicken, and frozen veggies. Cook for an additional 3 or 4 minutes until everything is nicely combined.
- Step 5
Assemble the pie by first placing the crust into one half of the pie pan so that it drapes over the other side and so that there is a little bit hanging over the side. See photo above. Pour the chicken filling into the crust and fold the crust over top of the filling. Cut off any excess dough, press together to seal the crust shut, and using your fingers, crimp the edges. HERE is how to properly crimp the edges.
- Step 6
Poke a few holes in the top of the pie with a fork.
For the apple pie
- Step 7
In a large bowl, mix together the sliced apples, lemon juice, sugars, cinnamon, nutmeg, salt, and flour. Stir until fully combined.
- Step 8
Pour the apple mixture into your pie crust and even it out so that none of the apples are sticking up much higher than any other. I usually use my fingers to arrange the apples in a neat manner.
- Step 9
Now is the time for the top crust. I did a simple lattice crust for the top. You can also cover the top in the same way that we covered the chicken pot pie side but just be sure to make a few slits in the top for the pie to breath. For the lattice, you'll want to cut the crust in half 60/40. Place the 60 into the pan and use the 40 to cut into thin strips for the lattice.
- Step 10
Place the whole pie into the oven and bake for 25-30 minutes.
- Step 11
Let cool slightly, slice, and ENJOY!
@food-with-feeling
I’m Brita! I’m the writer, photographer, videography, cookbook author, and chef around these parts. I’ve enjoyed testing and creating new recipes and sharing them with you! I have one simple goal: to help you cook more wholesome, simple and DELICIOUS meat free recipes whether you’re vegetarian, vegan, or a carnivore looking to incorporate more veggie forward recipes into your life!
Per serving
Be the first to review this recipe and earn a 20% Bonus
Level up & unlock free Premium by reviewing recipes!
More Recipes From Food with Feeling
From the creator of this recipe
No Recipes Available
Recommended Recipes for you
Tailored to your preferences














